School Uniforms Should Not Be Mandatory

 

Tablo reader up chevron

School Uniforms Should Not Be Mandatory

It is highly debated across America that schools should require their students to wear a uniform throughout the school day, with this opinion, there exist many articles that support this claim. The so-called benefits that these articles claim, they there is research that refutes these claims, and its truth outweighs the benefits that are stated from these supporting claims. We can examine studies conducted by professionals, and statistics derived from reliable and reputable sources, that support the statement that schools should not require their students to wear a uniform during the school day. The enforcement of uniforms in schools violate a student’s freedom of expression, as supported by the first amendment in the constitution of the United States. Schools provide us our education and are the gateway for the future of the country, and the countries value of thought and expression in which America was founded on. 

School uniforms conflict with freedom of expression, and creating schools into uniformity that erases diversity from school grounds. Students should be able to express their emotions, thoughts, and views on politics. Attire sends a silent message to the viewers, and tells a story about the wearers, states their opinion and affiliations, and enables the wearer to be seen as they want to be. (Rowland) Lee Rowland, affiliated with ACLU Nevada, brought forth the argument, presenting that school officials are likely to argue that school is exclusive to learning, while students can exercise freedom of expression outside of school. In “Four Reasons Public Schools Should Think Twice Before Instituting School Uniform Policies”, Lee Rowland argues: But the two simply aren’t mutually exclusive... In fact, the differences among student outfits are fertile grounds for identifying their likes and dislikes . . . and showcasing the breadth of choice and diversity among young people. These are tools that teachers and other students can use to increase the educational experience, by getting to know students as fully-formed individuals, and talking about divergent socioeconomic and cultural norms.

 

There are many advantages and disadvantages to having school uniforms and they are becoming a common school uniforms debate. Students, teachers, and parents all have mixed feelings about students wearing uniforms. Some might say that wearing school uniforms takes away students’ freedom of self expression and others might say that all learners need to look alike and the uniforms are for discipline purposes. Nonetheless, this is a topic that is constantly debated in public school.

A common argument that is against school uniforms is that students can’t fully express themselves. This is true to some extent, but self expression doesn’t only involve the clothes you wear. Students can express themselves by the way they do their hair, wearing jewelry or not, and by the shoes they wear. Another concern about school uniforms is that teachers can’t identify students with violent tendencies and deal with them. If students are allowed to wear whatever they want, some will come to school with gang related colors which can lead to the formation of cliques. Just because students are not allowed to pick out what clothes they want to wear to school everyday, doesn’t mean that they can’t express themselves. Students can wear whatever they want outside of school. From this perspective, uniforms put all students at the same level, which will most likely eliminate discrimination. An argument that is commonly raised by parents is that school uniforms are too expensive. The parents argue that having to buy school uniforms on top of regular clothes for the weekend can become very costly, especially those with multiple children. They said that school is already way too expensive, so they shouldn’t add on to the cost by making them buy uniforms.

 

A valid point was made about how some people say that uniforms take away students individuality and self expression. This article says, "They decide to teach us about people like Rosa Parks, Susan B. Anthony and Booker T. Washington... We learn about how these people expressed themselves and conquered and we can't even express ourselves in the hallways” (“ProCon.org”). Some parents made a very valid point about uniforms being too expensive because parents are already paying a lot and they might not be able to afford the uniforms. An article stated, “According to cost of school uniforms statistics, some parents pay significantly more for uniforms than regular clothes for their children, with an average of a few outfits costing around $600” (“Statistics on School Uniforms”). The cost of uniforms really depends on the type of uniform that is required at a particular school.

There are many benefits that go along with having school uniforms. School uniforms reduce distractions in the classroom by creating a common ground for everyone and they allow students to focus on their academics instead of what they and other people are wearing. For example, “Two thirds of parents (66%) think wearing a school uniform puts students on a level playing field and makes their life easier” (“Research shows wearing a school uniform helps to reduce bullying”). Studies show that school uniforms help prevent bullying throughout the school. The article stated, “60% of students who were identified as bullies in grades 6 to 9 went on to have at least one criminal conviction by the time they turned 24. School intervention programs (which includes school uniforms) are reported at reducing bullying by 30-50%” (“Our Family World”). Therefore, school uniforms are very beneficial for students and the school.

 

The best compromise for being either for or against school uniforms is a school dress code. The school dress code specifies the type of clothing that the students are allowed to wear to school. For example, the dress code could specify how long the students shorts should be, whether or not they can have holes in their pants, and what kind of pants and shirts they can wear. Dress codes can reduce behaviors that are often expressed through clothing such as violence or promiscuity. A school dress code allows the students to pick out what clothes they want to wear to school each day and it also allows them to express themselves. Having a dress code allows everyone in the school will be happier because they aren’t wearing uniforms and they get to pick out what they want to wear.

Comment Log in or Join Tablo to comment on this chapter...
~

You might like Gordon's other books...